1 eval, 4 runs, from 2026-11-02 03:28 to 2026-11-02 03:29 UTC.
Series by model.
compare-classify
Dataset: compare-classify c03cd101 (12 cases).
Trial pass rate over time
inclusionai/ling-3.0-flash(2 runs)
z-ai/glm-5.3-flash(2 runs)
X: start time of the run (UTC). Y: passed / (passed + failed) trials of the run. Whisker: 95% Wilson interval. Hollow diamond, dashed line and a break in the line: the dataset or the trial policy differs from the previous run of the series, so the rates do not compare. Dotted line with a value: the run where prompt changed to that value.
Latest completed run per series
Select the start time of a run to see its cases and trials.
Per case, the trial pass rate over the completed runs in the window. At 0% and 100%, the task gives the same result each time; the bins between hold the cases where it is not consistent.
inclusionai/ling-3.0-flash
12 cases, 2 runs
z-ai/glm-5.3-flash
12 cases, 2 runs
Score distributions
Per scorer, the score values of all trials of the completed runs in the window, in 10 bins from 0 to 1.
category@1
inclusionai/ling-3.0-flash
72 scores
z-ai/glm-5.3-flash
72 scores
summary@rubric@1
inclusionai/ling-3.0-flash
72 scores
z-ai/glm-5.3-flash
72 scores
Flips
No flips since the previous completed run of each series.
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and the CSV export feature crashes every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that names both customer problems, the CSV export crash and the double charge this month, in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket states (it does not invent causes, amounts, or dates), so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The CSV export crashes and the customer was charged twice this month."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems, the CSV export crashing and being charged twice this month, in neutral words. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says; 'every time' is paraphrased as a plain statement of the crash, which is a minor simplification but not an…Show all 315 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems, the CSV export crashing and being charged twice this month, in neutral words. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says; 'every time' is paraphrased as a plain statement of the crash, which is a minor simplification but not an invented fact.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer reports being charged twice this month and experiencing a crash when exporting to CSV."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems (double charge this month and crash when exporting to CSV) in neutral wording, without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "Customer was charged twice for their March subscription and is requesting a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund of one charge. It adds no facts not in the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and is requesting a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and is requesting a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund for one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
feature-and-loginpass (3/3)
Tags: two-problems
Trial 1 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer is unable to log in due to a 'session expired' error since this morning, and also requests a dark mode feature for working at night."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is a single English sentence that states both customer problems: the login failure showing 'session expired' since this morning, and the request for a dark mode for night work. Every detail matches the ticket, and nothing is invented.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The user cannot log in due to a 'session expired' error, and also requests a dark mode feature for working at night."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the login failure with a 'session expired' error and the request for dark mode for night work. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'since this morning' is omitted, which is not an invented fact.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer cannot log in due to a 'session expired' error, and requests a dark mode feature for working at night."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the login failure with a 'session expired' error, and the request for dark mode for night work. It adds no invented facts; it omits the 'since this morning' timing, which is a dropped detail rather than an invention.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
german-double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and is requesting a refund for one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is a single English sentence that states both customer problems: being charged twice this month and requesting a refund for one payment. It adds no facts beyond the German ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice in one month and is requesting a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems: being charged twice this month and requesting a refund of one payment. It adds no facts beyond the German ticket, which says they were charged twice this month and asks for one payment refunded.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and is requesting a refund for one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems: being charged twice this month and requesting a refund for one payment. It adds no facts beyond the German ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
how-topass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer wants to know how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's single problem (wanting to know how to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, with no invented facts. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "Customer wants to know how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's single problem (wanting to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, with no added facts beyond the ticket's text. It meets the rubric's requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer wants to know how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (wanting to know how to move a folder to another team) in neutral words. It adds no facts beyond the ticket's question, so it meets every requirement of the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
invite-greyedpass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "After upgrading to the Team plan, the Invite button is greyed out and colleagues cannot be added."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out and colleagues cannot be added. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, since 'after upgrading to the Team plan' matches the ticket's 'I upgraded to Team'.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "User upgraded to Team plan but the Invite button is greyed out and cannot add colleagues."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out and the customer cannot add colleagues. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, which says the customer upgraded to Team, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "After upgrading to the Team plan, the Invite button is greyed out and the customer cannot add colleagues."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out after upgrading to Team, and the customer cannot add colleagues. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
japanese-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating the same problem neutrally ('crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF') without adding any facts. It meets the single-sentence, English, neutral, no-invention requirem…Show all 305 charactersShow less
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating the same problem neutrally ('crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF') without adding any facts. It meets the single-sentence, English, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF, with no added facts. It states the single problem neutrally, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally and adds no invented facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
login-after-updatepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "After a recent update, the customer cannot log in because the app reports their password is incorrect despite them believing it is correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: they cannot log in, and the app reports their password as incorrect although they believe it is correct. The only slight embellishment is calling the update 'recent', which is a close paraphrase of 'last update' and not…Show all 329 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: they cannot log in, and the app reports their password as incorrect although they believe it is correct. The only slight embellishment is calling the update 'recent', which is a close paraphrase of 'last update' and not a substantive invented fact.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer cannot log in because the app incorrectly reports their password as wrong."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem (cannot log in because the app reports a wrong password) in neutral terms, without adding facts. The ticket also says 'since your last update' and asks whether it is a bug; the output omits the update timing and the bug question, but …Show all 517 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem (cannot log in because the app reports a wrong password) in neutral terms, without adding facts. The ticket also says 'since your last update' and asks whether it is a bug; the output omits the update timing and the bug question, but the rubric only requires each problem to be stated, and the main problem is covered. The phrase 'incorrectly reports' is a close paraphrase of the customer's claim that the password is not wrong, not an invented fact.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer cannot log in because the app reports their password is incorrect, though they believe the password is correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem: they cannot log in because the app says the password is wrong, though they believe it is correct. It invents no facts and omits none of the ticket's problems; the question of whether it is a bug is not a customer problem to restate, …Show all 422 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem: they cannot log in because the app says the password is wrong, though they believe it is correct. It invents no facts and omits none of the ticket's problems; the question of whether it is a bug is not a customer problem to restate, and the 'since your last update' detail is dropped but is context rather than a distinct problem. Neutral wording is used.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
paid-still-freepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan but the app still displays the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: charged $29 for Pro, and the app still shows the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; 'an hour ago' is omitted but that is not an invented fact, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both problems: the customer was charged $29 for Pro, and the app still shows the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket and uses neutral wording, though it omits the 'an hour ago' timing, which is not a required element of the problems themselves.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "Customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan, but the app still displays the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the $29 charge for Pro and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app closes itself after ten seconds following the recent update."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update. The sarcastic framing ('Wonderful news', 'so fast') is dropped, and no facts are added beyond the ticket's claim about the update and the ten-second closure.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app closes itself after ten seconds following the recent update."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update. The sarcastic 'Wonderful news' and 'so fast' framing are removed, and nothing is invented beyond the ticket's content. It meets the one-sentence, neutral, no-inv…Show all 320 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update. The sarcastic 'Wonderful news' and 'so fast' framing are removed, and nothing is invented beyond the ticket's content. It meets the one-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The rubric requires one English sentence stating each customer problem neutrally without invented facts. The input is sarcastic ('Wonderful news') but the actual problem is that the app closes itself after ten seconds, which the output states in one neutral sentence. The output adds no facts not in …Show all 341 charactersShow less
The rubric requires one English sentence stating each customer problem neutrally without invented facts. The input is sarcastic ('Wonderful news') but the actual problem is that the app closes itself after ten seconds, which the output states in one neutral sentence. The output adds no facts not in the ticket, so it meets the requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-passwordpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer is frustrated about having to reset their password repeatedly multiple times within a week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: frustration about repeatedly resetting their password. It adds no invented facts; 'multiple times within a week' is a fair paraphrase of 'fifth time this week', though it omits the exact count, which is not an addition. It …Show all 317 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: frustration about repeatedly resetting their password. It adds no invented facts; 'multiple times within a week' is a fair paraphrase of 'fifth time this week', though it omits the exact count, which is not an addition. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer is frustrated about having to reset their password multiple times within a single week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: having to reset the password multiple times in one week. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though it frames the customer as frustrated, which is a reasonable reading of the sarcasm rather than an invented detail. The 'fif…Show all 372 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: having to reset the password multiple times in one week. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though it frames the customer as frustrated, which is a reasonable reading of the sarcasm rather than an invented detail. The 'fifth time' count is omitted but not invented, so the requirements are met.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer is required to reset their password repeatedly."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: they must reset their password repeatedly. The ticket says it is the fifth reset this week, so 'repeatedly' is supported and adds no invented fact. The sarcasm is not stated as a complaint, but the rubric only requires each…Show all 373 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: they must reset their password repeatedly. The ticket says it is the fifth reset this week, so 'repeatedly' is supported and adds no invented fact. The sarcasm is not stated as a complaint, but the rubric only requires each problem to be stated neutrally without invention, which the output does.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
share-errorpass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share displays an error 500 and no sharing link is generated."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share shows an error 500, and no link appears (rephrased as no sharing link is generated). It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share produces an error 500 and no sharing link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share produces an error 500, and no sharing link appears. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share shows an error 500 and no link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share shows an error 500, and no link appears. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The CSV export feature crashes every time, and the customer was charged twice this month."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: the CSV export crashes every time, and the card was charged twice this month. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'the customer was charged twice' is a neutral restatement of 'you charged my card twice' and 'CSV export fea…Show all 351 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: the CSV export crashes every time, and the card was charged twice this month. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'the customer was charged twice' is a neutral restatement of 'you charged my card twice' and 'CSV export feature' is a mild paraphrase rather than an addition.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer reports that exporting to CSV crashes every time, and their card was charged twice this month."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems (CSV export crashes every time, and card charged twice this month) in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The CSV export feature crashes every time, and the customer was charged twice this month."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both problems: the CSV export crashes every time, and the customer was charged twice this month. It uses neutral wording and adds no facts beyond the ticket ("CSV export feature" is a mild paraphrase of "export to CSV", not an invented fact).
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and is requesting a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund for one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and is requesting a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is a single English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund for one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "Customer was charged twice for their March subscription and is requesting a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
feature-and-loginpass (3/3)
Tags: two-problems
Trial 1 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature and reports being unable to log in since this morning due to a 'session expired' error."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request (for night work, which is implied but omitted) and the login failure with the 'session expired' error since this morning. It adds no invented facts, and the only omission is the reason for wanting …Show all 364 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request (for night work, which is implied but omitted) and the login failure with the 'session expired' error since this morning. It adds no invented facts, and the only omission is the reason for wanting dark mode, which is not a required problem. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer requests dark mode and cannot log in due to a 'session expired' error since this morning."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request and the login failure with the 'session expired' error since this morning. It adds no facts beyond the ticket (the 'working at night' reason is omitted, which is acceptable since the rubric only asks f…Show all 330 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request and the login failure with the 'session expired' error since this morning. It adds no facts beyond the ticket (the 'working at night' reason is omitted, which is acceptable since the rubric only asks for each problem to be stated).
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature and reports being unable to log in since this morning due to a 'session expired' error."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is a single English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request (for night work) and the login failure with 'session expired' since this morning. It adds no invented facts; the 'since this morning' and 'session expired' details are both in the ticket, and …Show all 423 charactersShow less
The output is a single English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request (for night work) and the login failure with 'session expired' since this morning. It adds no invented facts; the 'since this morning' and 'session expired' details are both in the ticket, and the 'for working at night' reason is omitted, which is acceptable since the rubric only requires each problem to be stated.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
german-double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and is requesting a refund for one of the two charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer was charged twice this month and asks for a refund of one of the two charges. Both points appear in the German ticket, and the sentence adds no facts such as amounts, dates, or causes.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: being charged twice this month and requesting a refund of one of the two payments. It adds no facts beyond the German ticket and uses neutral wording.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund for one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the two things the German ticket says: the customer was charged twice this month and asks for a refund of one of the payments. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, and the wording is neutral.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
how-topass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer is asking how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that restates the customer's problem (wanting to move a folder to another team) in neutral words. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement of the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer wants to know how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's single problem (wanting to know how to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the rubric's requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "Customer wants to know how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (wanting to know how to move a folder to another team) in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
invite-greyedpass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "After upgrading to Team plan, the Invite button is greyed out and the customer cannot add colleagues."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out after the Team upgrade, and the customer cannot add colleagues. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "After upgrading to the Team plan, the user cannot invite colleagues because the Invite button is greyed out."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems neutrally: the upgrade to Team, the greyed-out Invite button, and the inability to invite colleagues. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "After upgrading to the Team plan, the Invite button is greyed out and the customer cannot add colleagues."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out after upgrading to Team, and the customer cannot add colleagues. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
japanese-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally without adding facts. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input is a Japanese ticket saying the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally without adding any facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF, with no added facts. It states the single problem neutrally, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
login-after-updatepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer cannot log in because the app reports their password is incorrect even though their password is correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (cannot log in, app says password is incorrect though it is correct) in neutral wording without adding facts. The ticket also asks whether this is a bug, which the rubric does not require to be restated as a problem, so the single…Show all 332 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (cannot log in, app says password is incorrect though it is correct) in neutral wording without adding facts. The ticket also asks whether this is a bug, which the rubric does not require to be restated as a problem, so the single problem is captured accurately.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer cannot log in after a recent update despite their password being correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem: they cannot log in after a recent update though their password is correct. It adds no invented facts; 'recent update' paraphrases 'since your last update' and the customer's question about a bug is not required by the rubric. It …Show all 362 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem: they cannot log in after a recent update though their password is correct. It adds no invented facts; 'recent update' paraphrases 'since your last update' and the customer's question about a bug is not required by the rubric. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer cannot log in because the app reports their password is incorrect despite them believing it is correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem: they cannot log in because the app says the password is wrong while they believe it is correct. It states the problem neutrally and adds no facts beyond the ticket (it does not invent a cause or a bug confirmation). The ticket's ques…Show all 379 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem: they cannot log in because the app says the password is wrong while they believe it is correct. It states the problem neutrally and adds no facts beyond the ticket (it does not invent a cause or a bug confirmation). The ticket's question 'Is this a bug?' is not a problem statement, so omitting it is acceptable.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
paid-still-freepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "Customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the $29 charge for Pro and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, and the 'an hour ago' timing is omitted rather than invented, which is acceptable since the rubric only forbids adding …Show all 312 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the $29 charge for Pro and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, and the 'an hour ago' timing is omitted rather than invented, which is acceptable since the rubric only forbids adding information.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "Customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: charged $29 for the Pro plan, and the app still shows the Free plan. It adds no facts not in the ticket (it omits the 'an hour ago' timing, which is not an invented fact). It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the $29 charge for Pro and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-crashpass (2/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds. The sarcastic framing ('wonderful news', 'so fast') is dropped, and no facts are invented. It meets the rubric's requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app closes itself after ten seconds following the update."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update. The sarcastic framing ('Wonderful news', 'so fast') is dropped, and no facts are invented beyond the ticket's claims about the update and the ten-second closing.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 fail
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app closes itself after ten seconds following a recent update."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1fail 0.00
The output is one neutral sentence stating that the app closes itself after ten seconds, which matches the ticket. However, it adds 'recent' before 'update', a timing detail the ticket never states, so it invents a fact the rubric forbids.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-passwordpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer has had to reset their password five times in one week and is frustrated by the repeated password resets."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problems neutrally: having to reset the password five times this week and frustration with it. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, which mentions the fifth reset this week and sarcasm about the feature; calling the customer 'frustrated' i…Show all 367 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problems neutrally: having to reset the password five times this week and frustration with it. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, which mentions the fifth reset this week and sarcasm about the feature; calling the customer 'frustrated' is a reasonable reading of the sarcasm rather than an invented fact.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer has had to reset their password five times within a single week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer must reset their password five times in one week, which matches the ticket's problem in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; the sarcasm is removed without inventing details. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention r…Show all 312 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer must reset their password five times in one week, which matches the ticket's problem in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; the sarcasm is removed without inventing details. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Customer is frustrated about having to reset their password multiple times within a single week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem neutrally: having to reset the password multiple times in one week. It adds no invented facts; 'frustrated' reflects the sarcastic tone of the ticket, and 'multiple times' is a reasonable neutral rendering of 'fifth time this week…Show all 368 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem neutrally: having to reset the password multiple times in one week. It adds no invented facts; 'frustrated' reflects the sarcastic tone of the ticket, and 'multiple times' is a reasonable neutral rendering of 'fifth time this week'. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
share-errorpass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share shows an error 500 and no sharing link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share shows an error 500, and no sharing link appears. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share shows an error 500 and no sharing link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share shows an error 500, and no sharing link appears. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share shows an error 500 and no link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share shows an error 500, and no link appears. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer reports that CSV export crashes and that they were charged twice on their card this month."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems (CSV export crashes every time is rendered as 'CSV export crashes', and being charged twice this month) in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; the 'every time' frequency is dropped, which omits a detail but does n…Show all 319 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems (CSV export crashes every time is rendered as 'CSV export crashes', and being charged twice this month) in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; the 'every time' frequency is dropped, which omits a detail but does not invent anything.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month, and the CSV export crashes every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems (CSV export crashes every time, charged twice this month) in neutral wording without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and CSV export crashes every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both problems: the CSV export crashing every time and being charged twice this month. It states them neutrally and adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for the March subscription and requests a refund of one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the double charge for the March subscription and the request for a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and requests a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the double charge for the March subscription and the request for a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for the March subscription and requests a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the double charge for the March subscription and the request for a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
feature-and-loginpass (3/3)
Tags: two-problems
Trial 1 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature for working at night and reports that since this morning the app shows 'session expired' on every login attempt."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: the request for dark mode for night work and the login failure showing 'session expired' since this morning. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'every login attempt' is a close paraphrase of 'every time' and 'requests a f…Show all 329 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: the request for dark mode for night work and the login failure showing 'session expired' since this morning. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'every login attempt' is a close paraphrase of 'every time' and 'requests a feature' is a neutral framing.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature and reports that since this morning the app shows 'session expired' and prevents them from logging in."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the dark mode request and the login failure showing 'session expired' since this morning. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature and reports that since this morning they cannot log in because the app shows 'session expired' every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: a requested dark mode feature and a login failure since this morning with 'session expired' every time. It uses neutral wording and adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
german-double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both problems in the ticket: the customer was charged twice this month and asks for a refund of one of the two payments. It adds no facts beyond the German ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund for one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund for one of the two payments. Both problems in the German ticket are covered in neutral wording, and no facts are added.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that covers both points in the German ticket: the customer was charged twice this month and asks for a refund of one payment. It uses neutral wording and adds no facts that the ticket does not state.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
how-topass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer asks how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (asking how to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer asks how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (asking how to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, adding no facts beyond the ticket text. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer asks how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is a single English sentence that states the customer's problem (wanting to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the one-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The invite button is greyed out and cannot be used after upgrading to the Team plan."
}
Scores
category@1fail 0.00
expected "account", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1fail 0.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem: the Invite button is greyed out after upgrading to Team. However, it omits the second problem, that the customer cannot add colleagues, so not every problem is stated. It invents no facts, but the rubric requires each problem to be s…Show all 306 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem: the Invite button is greyed out after upgrading to Team. However, it omits the second problem, that the customer cannot add colleagues, so not every problem is stated. It invents no facts, but the rubric requires each problem to be stated.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 fail
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The invite button is greyed out and prevents the user from adding colleagues after upgrading to Team."
}
Scores
category@1fail 0.00
expected "account", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out and the user cannot add colleagues after upgrading to Team. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 fail
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The invite button is greyed out and cannot be used to add colleagues after upgrading to the Team plan."
}
Scores
category@1fail 0.00
expected "account", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems, the Invite button being greyed out and being unable to add colleagues. The phrase 'after upgrading to the Team plan' is supported by the ticket's 'I upgraded to Team', and no facts are invented.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
japanese-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally without adding facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally with no added facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally without adding any facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
login-after-updatepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Since the last update, the customer cannot log in because the app says their password is wrong, which they say it is not, and they ask whether this is a bug."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence and states the customer's problems neutrally: cannot log in since the last update, the app says the password is wrong though they say it is not, and they ask if it is a bug. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Since the last update, the customer cannot log in because the app reports their password as wrong, which the customer says is incorrect."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is a single English sentence that states the login failure, the app's password-wrong message, and the customer's claim that the password is correct, all in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, and the 'since the last update' timing matches the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Since the latest update, the customer cannot log in because the app reports their password is wrong, which they dispute, and they ask whether this is a bug."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems: they cannot log in, the app reports a wrong password which they dispute, and they ask whether it is a bug. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; 'since the latest update' is a faithful paraphrase of 'since your last update'. Neutral w…Show all 337 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems: they cannot log in, the app reports a wrong password which they dispute, and they ask whether it is a bug. It adds no facts beyond the ticket; 'since the latest update' is a faithful paraphrase of 'since your last update'. Neutral wording is used, so the rubric is met.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
paid-still-freepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged $29 for Pro an hour ago, and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both problems: being charged $29 for Pro an hour ago and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket and uses neutral wording.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the $29 charge for Pro an hour ago, and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The customer praises the update for making the app fast and reports that the app now closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update. It adds the praise framing ('praises the update for making the app fast'), which is in the ticket, so no invented facts. The rubric requires each problem sta…Show all 421 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update. It adds the praise framing ('praises the update for making the app fast'), which is in the ticket, so no invented facts. The rubric requires each problem stated neutrally; the sarcasm is recast as praise plus a reported problem, which is acceptable and adds nothing unsupported.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "After the update, the app closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: after the update, the app closes itself after ten seconds. The sarcastic framing ('wonderful news', 'so fast') is dropped, and no facts are invented beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The customer reports that after the update, the app closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem neutrally: after the update the app closes itself after ten seconds. The sarcasm in the ticket is removed, and it adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-passwordpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer complains sarcastically about having to reset their password five times this week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (having to reset their password five times this week) in neutral words, and it adds no facts beyond the ticket. It labels the tone as sarcastic, which the ticket does convey, so nothing is invented.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer has had to reset their password five times this week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: they have had to reset their password five times this week. The ticket's sarcasm is removed and no facts are invented, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer reports having to reset their password for the fifth time this week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence and states the customer's problem neutrally: they had to reset their password for the fifth time this week. It adds no invented facts, and the ticket's sarcasm is not carried over as a claim, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
share-errorpass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The application displays a 500 error and does not generate a link when the user clicks the Share button."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: a 500 error appears on clicking Share, and no link is generated. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, with only minor rewording like 'the application' and 'the user'.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The sharing function displays a 500 error and fails to generate a link."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the Share action shows a 500 error and no link is generated. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share returns an error 500 and no share link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: clicking Share returns an error 500, and no share link appears. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month, and the CSV export crashes every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems (the CSV export crashes every time, and the card was charged twice this month) in neutral wording. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice on their card this month, and the CSV export crashes every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both problems neutrally: the CSV export crashes every time, and the card was charged twice this month. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement of the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
The export to CSV crashes every time. Also, you charged my card twice this month.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice on their card this month and reports that exporting to CSV crashes every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: the card was charged twice this month and CSV export crashes every time. It stays neutral and adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and requests a refund of one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and wants a refund for one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the double charge for the March subscription and the request for a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I was charged twice for my March subscription. Please refund one of the charges.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice for their March subscription and requests a refund of one of the charges."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged twice for the March subscription and requesting a refund of one charge. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
feature-and-loginpass (3/3)
Tags: two-problems
Trial 1 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode for working at night and reports that since this morning the app shows 'session expired' on every login attempt."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: the dark mode request for night work and the login failure showing 'session expired' since this morning. Its wording ('on every login attempt') matches the ticket's 'every time' without adding any facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature, and since this morning cannot log in because the app shows 'session expired' every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that names both customer problems: the request for dark mode and the inability to log in since this morning with 'session expired' shown every time. It adds no facts beyond the ticket (the ticket's 'working at night' rationale is omitted, which is not an invented f…Show all 305 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that names both customer problems: the request for dark mode and the inability to log in since this morning with 'session expired' shown every time. It adds no facts beyond the ticket (the ticket's 'working at night' rationale is omitted, which is not an invented fact).
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Hi! A dark mode would be great for working at night. Also, since this morning the app does not let me log in: it shows 'session expired' every time.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer requests a dark mode feature and reports that since this morning they cannot log in because the app shows 'session expired' every time."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both problems: the dark mode request and the login failure with 'session expired' since this morning. The 'because' links the login failure to the session-expired message, which the ticket's colon structure supports, and nothing is invented.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
german-double-chargepass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both points in the ticket: the customer was charged twice this month and asks for a refund of one of the two payments. It adds no facts that the German ticket does not contain.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both of the customer's problems: being charged twice this month and requesting a refund of one payment. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, and its wording is neutral.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Ich wurde diesen Monat zweimal belastet. Bitte erstatten Sie mir eine der beiden Zahlungen.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged twice this month and requests a refund of one of the two payments."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems, the double charge this month and the request for a refund of one payment, in neutral wording. It adds no facts that the German ticket does not contain.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
how-topass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer asks how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (wanting to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer asks how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's single problem (wanting to move a folder to another team) in neutral words, without adding any facts not in the ticket. It meets the rubric's requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
How do I move a folder to another team?
Output
{
"category": "other",
"summary": "The customer wants to know how to move a folder to another team."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "other", got "other"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (wanting to know how to move a folder to another team) in neutral words. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The invite button is disabled after upgrading to the Team plan, preventing the user from adding colleagues."
}
Scores
category@1fail 0.00
expected "account", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is disabled after upgrading to Team, and the user cannot add colleagues. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, which says the button is greyed out and the user cannot invite colleagues.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 fail
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The invite button is greyed out, preventing the user from adding colleagues after upgrading to the Team plan."
}
Scores
category@1fail 0.00
expected "account", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out and the user cannot add colleagues after upgrading to Team. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'after upgrading to the Team plan' is a restatement of the ticket's 'I upgraded to Team'…Show all 319 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out and the user cannot add colleagues after upgrading to Team. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, though 'after upgrading to the Team plan' is a restatement of the ticket's 'I upgraded to Team', not an invention.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
I upgraded to Team, but the Invite button is greyed out and I cannot add my colleagues.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The invite button is greyed out and prevents the user from adding colleagues despite upgrading to the Team plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence and states the customer's problems neutrally: the Invite button is greyed out and the user cannot add colleagues after upgrading to Team. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
japanese-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: non-english
Trial 1 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally without adding facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, which captures the single problem neutrally without adding facts.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
PDFを開こうとするたびにアプリが落ちます。
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The input (Japanese) says the app crashes every time the user tries to open a PDF. The output is one English sentence stating that the app crashes every time the customer tries to open a PDF, with no added facts. It states the single problem neutrally and meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
login-after-updatepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Since the last update the customer cannot log in because the app reports their password as wrong, and they ask whether this is a bug."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems neutrally: cannot log in since the last update, the app reports the password as wrong, and they ask if it is a bug. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Since the last update, the customer cannot log in because the app says their password is wrong, although they say it is correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems: cannot log in since the last update, and the app reports a wrong password although they say it is correct. It adds no invented facts; the question 'is this a bug' is omitted, which is acceptable since the rubric asks only for the cu…Show all 354 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems: cannot log in since the last update, and the app reports a wrong password although they say it is correct. It adds no invented facts; the question 'is this a bug' is omitted, which is acceptable since the rubric asks only for the customer's problems. Both problems are stated neutrally.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Since your last update I cannot log in. It says my password is wrong, but it is not. Is this a bug?
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "Since the last update, the customer cannot log in because the app reports their password as wrong, although they state the password is correct."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems neutrally: cannot log in since the last update, and the app reports the password as wrong though they say it is correct. It adds no invented facts; the 'since the last update' and 'app reports' details are from the ticket, and the qu…Show all 400 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problems neutrally: cannot log in since the last update, and the app reports the password as wrong though they say it is correct. It adds no invented facts; the 'since the last update' and 'app reports' details are from the ticket, and the question 'is this a bug' is not a problem statement that is missing in a way that violates the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
paid-still-freepass (3/3)
Tags: ambiguous
Trial 1 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems: being charged $29 for Pro an hour ago and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket and stays neutral in wording.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the $29 charge for Pro an hour ago, and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
You charged my card $29 for Pro an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan.
Output
{
"category": "billing",
"summary": "The customer was charged $29 for the Pro plan an hour ago, but the app still shows the Free plan."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "billing", got "billing"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: being charged $29 for Pro an hour ago, and the app still showing the Free plan. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets every requirement of the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-crashpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "After the update, the app closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (the app closes itself after ten seconds following the update) in neutral words, without the sarcasm. It adds no facts beyond what the ticket says, so it meets every requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Since the update, the app closes itself ten seconds after being opened."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: the app closes itself ten seconds after opening since the update. The sarcastic framing ('wonderful news', 'so fast') is dropped, and no facts are invented beyond what the ticket says.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful news: your update made the app so fast that it now closes itself after ten seconds.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The customer praises that the app is now faster after the update, but reports that it closes itself after ten seconds."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the app is faster after the update, and it closes itself after ten seconds. The praise is sarcastic in the ticket, and the output reads it literally as praise, but it does not invent any facts beyond what the ticket say…Show all 492 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems neutrally: the app is faster after the update, and it closes itself after ten seconds. The praise is sarcastic in the ticket, and the output reads it literally as praise, but it does not invent any facts beyond what the ticket says. The rubric requires each problem to be stated neutrally, and the output's framing of the 'praise' is a mild misreading rather than an added fact, so it arguably still meets the requirement.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
sarcasm-passwordpass (3/3)
Tags: sarcasm
Trial 1 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer has had to reset their password five times this week and is frustrated."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (resetting password five times this week) in neutral words and adds only a mild emotional label ('frustrated') that is reasonably implied by the sarcastic ticket. It invents no facts beyond what the ticket says, though 'frustrated…Show all 403 charactersShow less
The output is one English sentence that states the customer's problem (resetting password five times this week) in neutral words and adds only a mild emotional label ('frustrated') that is reasonably implied by the sarcastic ticket. It invents no facts beyond what the ticket says, though 'frustrated' is a slight interpretation of the sarcasm, and the rubric's neutral-words requirement is largely met.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer states they have had to reset their password five times this week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem (having to reset their password five times this week) in neutral words, without adding facts not in the ticket. The ticket's sarcasm is dropped, which is consistent with neutral wording. It meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
Wonderful, I get to reset my password for the fifth time this week. Best feature ever.
Output
{
"category": "account",
"summary": "The customer states they have had to reset their password five times this week."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "account", got "account"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating the customer's problem neutrally: they have had to reset their password five times this week. It adds no facts not in the ticket, and the sarcasm is removed as the rubric requires.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
share-errorpass (3/3)
Tags: plain
Trial 1 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "The page shows a 500 error and no link appears when clicking the Share button."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence stating both customer problems neutrally: the page shows a 500 error and no link appears when clicking Share. It adds no facts beyond the ticket, so it meets the rubric.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 2 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "When the customer clicks Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that restates both customer problems (clicking Share shows an error 500, and no link appears) in neutral wording, changing only the pronoun to 'the customer' without adding any new facts. It meets the single-sentence, neutral, no-invention requirements.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…
Trace
Not recorded
Logs
Not recorded
Trial 3 pass
Input
When I click Share, the page shows an error 500 and no link appears.
Output
{
"category": "bug",
"summary": "Clicking Share shows an error 500 and no link appears."
}
Scores
category@1pass 1.00
expected "bug", got "bug"
summary@rubric@1pass 1.00
The output is one English sentence that states both customer problems in neutral wording: clicking Share shows an error 500, and no link appears. It adds no facts beyond the ticket.
Judge: template rubric@1 · model openrouter:anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 · prompt hash sha256:d6747825a1a9…